Book Book Book Book
Commentary Commentary RSS Reviews Podcasts_Audio Podcasts RSS Blog Links Archives Indexes
Eric Stener Carlson
The Saint Perpetuus Club of Buenos Aires
Reviewed by: Mario Guslandi © 2009

Tartarus Press, UK
Hardcover First edition
ISBN: 978-1-905784-16-5
Publication date: November 2009
233 pages; £ 25.00/ $ 45.00
Date reviewed: 12-12-2009

Index:  Horror  General Fiction  Fantasy

It's no secret that I'm not very fond of novels, especially in the field of dark fantasy. To me long fiction often gets boring, unless of exceptionally high quality (e.g. Dan Simmons' The Terror) or composed by several intertwining plots (e.g. the early Stephen King novels).

So when Ray Russell of Tartarus Press encouraged me to read The Saint Perpetuus Club of Buenos Aires, the debut novel of Eric Stener Carlson, I still had my reservations. However, knowing that Tartarus is always providing top-notch fiction either from the past or by new, emerging authors, I reluctantly started reading…and never stopped.

What kind of book is this? If I have to put a label on it, I'd be tempted to describe it as a cross between "magic realism" (but maybe I'm simply influenced by the south American location of the story) and supernatural fiction. Whatever it is, believe me, it's quite good, a captivating novel written in a sparkling style, precise yet imaginative.

Miguel is a civil servant living a rather dull existence. While browsing in a bookstore he discovers, hidden in the pages of an old copy of "Lives of Saints." under the entry Saint Perpetuus, a hand-written diary of a man claiming to be "a saint" and, more importantly, to know the secret of how to control time. Miguel's hunger for that powerful knowledge leads him across Buenos Aires more elusive bookstores to retrieve further copies of the books containing the additional chapters of that intriguing diary.

While Miguel, neglecting his job and his family, pursues his obsession, he realizes that members of the secret society named The Saint Perpetuus Club are scattered about the city, holding the key to the "salamanca" a forbidden, subterranean place where the Devil himself can satisfy human desires. I won't give away more to avoid spoiling things for the reader.

One of the more fascinating aspects of the book is the description, through the words of the anonymous "saint," of an enthralling Buenos Aires, with his subways, parks, avenues, hidden corners, each of them imbued with forgotten legends and old history that Carlson clearly knows in detail.

A native of Minnesota, Carlson first went in Argentina as a member of a forensics team looking for the remains of the victims of the military dictatorship which ruled the country in the ‘70s and early ‘80s and subsequently has written two non-fiction books dealing with tortures and disappearances occurred in that period (I Remember Julia: Voices of the Disappeared and The Pear Tree).

Living in Buenos Aires he got so acquainted with the city's historical and topographical secrets that he is able to make his characters in the novel perform an extraordinary journey in time and space within the famous capital. The engrossing plot and the enticing background make the story a delightful reading experience even though, to me at least, the final part of the novel appears to represent a sort of anti-climax, compared with the brilliant quality of the first 200 pages or so.


More Book Reviews
Review Archive
Shades of Grey: The Road to High Saffron
Jasper Fforde
Reviewed by
Rick Kleffel
Indigo Springs
A. M. Dellamonica
Reviewed by
Rick Kleffel

Sleepless
Charlie Huston
Reviewed by
Rick Kleffel


New to the Agony Column

02-09-10: Commentary : Douglas Clegg Returns to 'Neverland' : Is 1980's Horror Returning from the Grave?

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2009 Interview with David Drake, Part 2 / Complete : "I didn't have governor ... that is ... anything, endgame, was me killing somebody.""

02-08-10: Commentary : David Louis Edelman Completes Jump 225 : 'Geosynchron'

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2009 Interview with David Drake, Part 1 : "I'm still screwed up, but not nearly as badly as I was."

02-05-10: Commentary : DC Pierson is 'The Boy Who Couldn't Sleep and Never Had To' : The Insomnia Vibe

Agony Column Podcast News Report : Three Books with Alan Cheuse: Too Much Money, Dominick Dunne; The Privileges, Jonathan Dee; Adam Haslett, Union Atlantic; The Forty Rules of Love, Elif Shafak; Wild Child, T. C. Boyle

02-04-10: Commentary : David Grann and 'The Devil and Sherlock Holmes' : An Obsession with Obsession

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2010 Interview with Josh Sundquist : "It was a really amazing testament to the power of small-town America and to the power of organized religion at its best."

02-03-10: Commentary : James Rollins Unleashes 'The Altar of Eden' : Monsters at the Zoo

Agony Column Podcast News Report : Remembering Kage Baker : The View from Spyglass Park

02-02-10: Commentary : Michael Shea Hires 'The Extra' : The Last Job You Ever Have

Agony Column Podcast News Report : SF in SF, January 16, 2010 : A Panel Discussion with Terry Bisson, Jeff Carlson and Nancy Etchemendy

02-01-10: Commentary : 'He Walked Among Us' : Cassandra, John Titor and Norman Spinrad

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2010 Interview with Charlie Huston : "The prospect of things becoming deeply unhinged seemed very, very immediate"

01-29-10: Commentary : Henghis Hapthorn Meets 'Hespira' : Matthew Hughes Devolves the Universe

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2010 Interview with Jeff Brown : "I reached the point where I was just kind of done with me."

01-28-10: Commentary : A Review of 'Sleepless' by Charlie Huston : A Father Fears the Future

Agony Column Podcast News Report : Alan Beatts of Borderlands Books : Opening the Borderlands Café and the iPad

01-27-10: Commentary : Glen Cook Walks the 'Shadowline' : Every Old (Science Fiction) Thing is New (Space Opera) Again

Agony Column Podcast News Report : An Interview with Jeff Carlson at SF in SF on January 16, 2010 : "The bad guys never consider themselves the bad guys..."

01-26-10: Commentary : Chitra Bannerjee Divakaruni Finds 'One Amazing Thing' : Trapping the Storytellers

Agony Column Podcast News Report : An Interview with Nancy Etchemendy at SF in SF on January 16, 2010 : "We told a lot of stories in the family."

01-25-10: Commentary : Elizabeth Bear and 'Bone and Jewel Creatures' : From Obscurity to Ubiquity

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2010 Interview with Jasper Fforde : "Proper novelling for a change.."

01-22-10: Commentary : 'Queen Victoria, Demon Hunter' by "A. E. Moorat" : Trash-Litifying National Treasures

Agony Column Podcast News Report : Thomas Frank : Bringing Back Glass-Steagall and the Price of Gold

01-21-10: Commentary : Keith Thompson is 'Once A Spy' : Father Knows Best

Agony Column Podcast News Report : SF in SF, January 16, 2010 : Nancy Etchemendy Reads from "Honey in the Wound"

01-20-10: Commentary : Reading the Newspaper : Why the San Francisco Chronicle Gets My Money

Agony Column Podcast News Report : SF in SF, January 16, 2010 : Jeff Carlson Reads from 'Plague Year'

01-19-10: Commentary : Gene Wolfe Moves into 'The Sorcerer's House' : Magical Surrealism

Agony Column Podcast News Report : Three Books with Alan Cheuse : Don Delillo: 'Point Omega,' Robert Stone: 'Fun With Problems,' Douglas Preston: 'Impact'

01-18-10: Commentary : George R. R. Martin and Gardner Dozois Bring On 'Warriors'n : An Anthology Waiting to Happen

Agony Column Podcast News Report : A 2009 Interview with Graham Joyce : "There is a battle between gravity and levity."

Commentary & Podcast Archive

Archives Indexes How to use the Agony Column Contact Us About Us